Climate Change & Weed Management: All Herbicide Efficacy Tables

How to use the tables:

First, locate the right table for the herbicide you’re using

Glyphosate (also known as RoundUp®) has its own table, while all other herbicides are in a separate table. For the “Other Herbicides” table, identify the brand/chemical you use based on the name and the group number

Then, see if the table has data for a weed species you’re trying to manage (e.g. Lambsquarters)

You can then see how the performance of the herbicide against the weed will change under different climate conditions.

  • A red “-“ means the herbicide will be less effective as the climate factor increases
  • A green “+” means the herbicide will be more effective as the climate factor increases
  • A blue “=” means there will be no change in efficacy
  • A white “ND” means there was no research data for that interaction
  • S and R refer to susceptible or resistant biotypes (e.g. "-R" means efficacy is reduced against resistant biotypes)

Glyphosate Efficacy

Photosynthetic pathwayCommon name
(Scientific name)
CO2TemperatureReference number
C3Common ragweed
(Ambriosia artemisiifolia)
+ (S+R)
– (R)
14, 9, 8
C3Giant ragweed
(Ambriosia trifida)
ND+9
C3Slender wild oat
(Avena barbata)
ND17
C3Rescuegrass
(Bromus cartharticus)
=ND17
C3Downy brome
(Bromus tectorum)
=3
C3Common lambsquarters
(Chenopodium album)
2, 10, 18
C3Canada thistle
(Cirsium arvense)
ND2, 4, 5, 19
C3Horseweed 
(Conyza canadensis)
10
C3Hairy fleabane
(Conyza bonariensis)
ND9
 
C3Quackgrass
(Elymus repens)
ND2, 4, 5
C3Prickly lettuce
(Lactuca serriola)
==3
C3Ryegrass
(Lolium rigidum)
ND2
C4Smooth pigweed
(Amaranthus hybridus)
ND+12
C4Palmer amaranth
(Amaranthus palmeri)
ND2
C4Redroot pigweed
(Amaranthus retroflexus)
=ND18
C4Yellow nutsedge
(Cyperus esculentus)
=ND7
C4Purple nutsedge
(Cyperus rotundus)
=ND7
C4Goosegrass
(Eleusine indica)
+ (R)
– (S)
ND20
C4Weeping lovegrass
(Eragostis curvula)
ND2, 6, 8
C4Johnsongrass
(Sorghum halepense)
ND2

Other Herbicides Efficacy

Herbicide (Trade name) 
and Commodity
Herbicide 
group number
Photosynthetic 
pathway
Common name
(Scientific Name)
CO2TemperatureDroughtHumidityReference Number
2-4, D Corn/soy4C3Wild buckwheat
(Polygonum convolvulus)
+NDNDND16
Atrazine (Aatrex®) Corn5C3Velvetleaf
(Abutilon theophrasti)
ND+NDND4
C3Common ragweed
(Ambriosia artemisiifolia)
ND+NDND4
C3Barley
(Hordeum vulgare)
ND+NDND16
Bentazon (Basasgran®) Corn/soy6C4Smooth pigweed
(Amaranthus hybridus)
ND+NDND12
Bromoxyynil (Maestro®) Corn6C4Kochia
(Kochia scoparia)
=NDNDND16
Dicamba(Clarity®) Corn4C4Kochia
(Kochia scoparia)
ND-NDND4
Glufosinate (Liberty®) Corn/soy10C3Wild oat
(Avena fatua)
NDNDND-16
C4Smooth pigweed
(Amaranthus hybridus)
ND+NDND12
C4Palmer amaranth
(Amaranthus palmeri)
NDNDND-16
C4Redroot pigweed
(Amaranthus retroflexus)
NDNDND-16
C4Common waterhemp
(Amaranthus tuburculatus)
NDNDND-16
C4Green foxtail
(Setaria viridis)
NDNDND-16
Halosulfuron (Permit®) Corn2C4Yellow nutsedge
(Cyperus esculentus)
=NDNDND7
C4Purple nutsedge
(Cyperus rotundus)
=NDNDND7
Imazethapyr (Pursuit®) Soy2C3Chickweed
(Stellaria media)
=NDNDND16
C4Barnyardgrass
(Echinochloa crus-galli)
= (S)* | - (R)*+ (S)* | - (R)*NDND1
Linuron (Lorox®) Corn/soy5C3Wild buckwheat
(Polygonum convolvulus)
-NDNDND4
C4Smooth pigweed
(Amaranthus hybridus)
ND+NDND11
Mesotrione (Callisto®) Corn27C4Palmer amaranth
(Amaranthus palmeri)
ND-NDND4
C4Common waterhemp
(Amaranthus tuburculatus)
NDNDND-16
Metolachlor (Dual Magnum®) Corn/soy15C4Smooth pigweed
(Amaranthus hybridus)
ND+NDND11
Metribuzin® Soy5C3Common lambsquarters
(Chenopodium album)
=NDNDND16
Paraquat (Gramoxone®) Soy22C3Horseweed
(Conyza canadensis)
ND-NDND14
C4Common waterhemp
(Amaranthus tuburculatus)
ND-NDND15
C4Large crabgrass
(Digitaria sanguinalis)
ND-NDND15
Pinoxaden (Axial XL)1C3Purple false brome
(Brachypodium hybridum)
ND+NDND3
Sethoxydim (Poast®) Soy1C3Wild oat
(Avena fatua)
=NDNDND16
C4Goosegrass
(Eleusine indica)
NDND-ND15

The efficacy of herbicides is expected to either decreaseincrease, or maintain effectiveness depending on the specific chemistryspecies, and climate factor(s) involved. This web page focuses on problematic weeds across a variety of cropping systems and provides data sourced from the current scientific literature to help build an understanding of how these future shifts might affect weed management. Please note that research to date has mostly focused on glyphosate, which limits information on effective substitutions in weather conditions where glyphosate is less effective. Additionally, only a small group of weed species have been studied, so there are many common weeds with no available information on changing herbicide efficacy. However, given the currently available literature, we conclude that photosynthetic pathway, herbicide resistance, and herbicide chemistries will have the most impact on efficacy and management.  

See our other web pages and fact sheets in this series for information on photosynthetic pathways, herbicide resistance effects, and climate change impacts for additional commodity areas. Growers should refer to the current Cornell Pest Management Guidelines for information on pesticides labeled for use in New York State. Contact an area extension specialist for current information on best practices in weed management and herbicide rotation.

 

Credits

This content was authored by Caroline Marschner, Sharon Bachman, Isabella Colucci, John Pirrung, Sophie Westbrook, and Toni DiTommaso. We would also like to express our gratitude again to Vipan Kumar and Bryan Brown for their invaluable support and expert input on this project and these fact sheets.

Disclaimers

Read the pesticide label prior to use. The label is the law.  The information contained on this page is not a substitute for a pesticide label. Trade names used herein are for convenience only; no endorsement of products is intended, nor is criticism of unnamed products implied.

This work was supported by a joint research and extension program funded by the Cornell University Agricultural Experiment Station (Hatch funds) and Cornell Cooperative Extension (Smith Lever funds) received from the National Institutes for Food and Agriculture (NIFA,) U.S. Department of Agriculture. Any opinions, findings, conclusions, or recommendations expressed in this publication are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the view of the U.S. Department of Agriculture.

References